Skip to main content

"Nobody talks about happiness"

 Peter Gumbel, lecturer in the school of journalism, Sciences Po.   Photo: Lea Crespi for the Observer

Interesting piece in today's Observer newspaper, drawing on a book published this week by British lecturer and journalist Peter Gumbel who works at Sciences Po in Paris. His book entitled On achève bien les écoliers? (Grasset) attacks the French education system for failing to build the self-esteem of French children. Nobody seems to talk about the happiness of children in schools. Whilst he agrees that the system has avoided "dumbing down" (unlike, he claims, the British system), it has been too negative towards children and makes them feel they are useless. French schoolchildren feel anxious, stressed and are frightened to speak out in class for fear of looking silly. He also mentions how poorly France trains its teachers (see my previous post) and seems to have forgotten that the basis of any good school is good teachers.

Anyway, here's the piece. Worth a look.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/sep/05/french-schools-pupils-feel-worthless

I guess it's hard to make a judgement on this as a virtual outsider, though his conclusions do not surprise me a bit. Pastoral support is not as well developed as in the UK, the curriculum encourages a "mug and jug" approach ("un style magistral"), extra-curricular activities are relatively limited, teachers are poorly trained and pressures on children are high. Teachers often complain that their schemes of work are "surchargés". Just as we are obsessed by our targets, league tables and grades, the French still over-value the mark out of 20 and the "moyenne". On the other hard, accountability is very limited when compared to the British system. If French teachers had to deal with our performance management system they would go on strike even before a hat was dropped.

And it's not as if standards are especially high. Despite what it says in the Observer article, international comparisons, for what they are worth, are not very flattering for the French.

Looks like the Observer and the Nouvel Obs are the only publications to latch on to this story so far. For more detail and comments see:

http://hebdo.nouvelobs.com/sommaire/notre-epoque/100417/l-ecole-casse-t-elle-nos-enfants.html

Are countries introspective when it comes to their education systems? We could learn so much from each other.

Comments

  1. This is so very true for colleges and lycees (maybe not for primary school). I witnessed year after year how my absolutely self-confident, articulate nine year old turns into a vegetable in his atrocious (but good) school. And the teachers were competent in their "matieres" but either old and cranky and distributing punishement instead of teaching, or young and unhappy and just unable to cope.

    And this year, his last, thankfully, the new "proviseurs" greeted them with menaces of what they cannot do. Not a single word of encouragement and welcome back after vacation. Sickening, really.

    As a historian and resercher myself I was just amused at the methodology of one half-mad teacher and her "textes a trous" that we filled in for hours without even knowing what we were reading. The punishement for not completing this completely futile exercise was 0. Those 0s destroyed my son's motivation for history.

    There are always shining exceptions (my son's German teachers) but they are so rare that one wonders how are they possible at all.

    Well, however, this system also builts character, but I wonder it is the one we want to dominate the next half a century.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Are countries introspective when it comes to their own education system?" A good question indeed... Often foreigners who have come to live and to love a country are able to have the needed insight to comment so aptly. A good illustration is Theodore Zeldin and his "The French" in particular. As a French teacher of FLE abroad I will endeavour to read Gumbel and expect to find there fluffy thoughts of mine articulated and substantiated eloquently and expertly.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'd also like to read his book, though when I checked it out on Amazon it looked horribly expensive.

    ReplyDelete

Post a comment

Popular posts from this blog

Delayed dictation

What is “delayed dictation”?

Instead of getting students to transcribe immediately what you say, or what a partner says, you can enforce a 10 second delay so that students have to keep running over in their heads what they have heard. Some teachers have even used the delay time to try to distract students with music.

It’s an added challenge for students but has significant value, I think. It reminds me of a phenomenon in music called audiation. I use it frequently as a singer and I bet you do too.

Audiation is thought to be the foundation of musicianship. It takes place when we hear and comprehend music for which the sound is no longer or may never have been present. You can audiate when listening to music, performing from notation, playing “by ear,” improvising, composing, or notating music. When we have a song going round in our mind we are audiating. When we are deliberately learning a song we are audiating.

In our language teaching case, though, the earworm is a word, chunk of l…

Sentence Stealers with a twist

Sentence Stealers is a reading aloud game invented by Gianfranco Conti. I'll describe the game to you, then suggest an extension of it which goes a bit further than reading aloud. By the way, I shouldn't need to justify the usefulness of reading aloud, but just in case, we are talking here about matching sounds to spellings, practising listening, pronunciation and intonation and repeating/recycling high frequency language patterns.

This is how it works:

Display around 15 sentences on the board, preferably ones which show language patterns you have been working on recently or some time ago.Hand out four cards or slips of paper to each student.On each card students must secretly write a sentence from the displayed list.Students then circulate around the class, approaching their classmates and reading a sentence from the displayed list. If the other person has that sentence on one of their cards, they must hand over the card. The other person then does the same, choosing a sentenc…

Using sentence builder frames for GCSE speaking and writing preparation

Some teachers have cottoned on to the fact that sentence builders (aka substitution tables) are a very useful tool for helping students prepare for their GCSE speaking and writing tests. My own hunch is that would help for students of all levels of proficiency, but may be particularly helpful for those likely to get lower grades, say between 3-6. Much depends, of course, on how complex you make the table.

To remind you, here is a typical sentence builder, as found on the frenchteacher site. The topic is talking about where you live. A word of warning - formatting blogs in Blogger is a nightmare when you start with Word documents, so apologies for any issues. It might have taken me another 30 minutes just to sort out the html code underlying the original document.


Setting work for home study

A major challenge for language teachers just now is selecting and sharing work with students to do at home. Here a few suggestions on the issue to add to your own. The sites I mention are the tip of the iceberg and focus mainly on French. I have stuck to free resources, not subscription sites.

By the way, I'm not getting into the use of tech here, as I have no great expertise on that. In any case, I imagine for younger learners especially it may be a question of setting other types of work.

ADVANCED

For advanced learners the job is not so tough. There is a plethora of listening, reading and grammar material they can use, whether it be from their textbooks, other resources shared electronically or online resources. You may have your favourites, but for a selection for French you can check out my links here and here. You may want to stick with topics on the syllabus, or free up students to read and listen more generally to what interests them.

One idea I used was to ask students to c…

"Ask and move" task

This is a lesson plan using an idea from our book Breaking the Sound Barrier (Conti and Smith, 2019). It's a task-based lesson adapted from an idea from Paul Nation and Jonathan Newton. It is aimed at Y10-11 pupils aiming at Higher Tier GCSE, but is easily adaptable to other levels and languages, including A-level. This has been posted as a resource on frenchteacher.net.

This type of lesson plan excites me more than many, because if it runs well, you get a classroom of busy communication when you can step back, monitor and occasionally intervene as students get on with listening, speaking and writing.